Tarot Censorship: Church Opposition Through History

BY NICOLE LAU

For centuries, tarot faced opposition from religious authorities who saw it as dangerous, demonic, or deceptive. From medieval sermons condemning card games to modern evangelical warnings about "occult doorways," tarot has been banned, burned, and denounced. Yet it survived, thrived, and ultimately won cultural acceptance. This is the story of tarot's struggle against censorship.

Early Opposition: Cards as Sin (1300s-1500s)

The Church's first concern with cards wasn't mysticism but gambling and idleness.

Gambling Condemnation: Playing cards (including tarot) were associated with gambling, which the Church condemned as sinful waste and potential ruin.

Idle Hands: Card games distracted from prayer, work, and moral living. Preachers warned against wasting time on frivolous entertainment.

Class Issues: Nobles playing tarot while peasants starved was seen as moral failure, though this was social critique more than religious condemnation.

Important: Early opposition targeted card games generally, not tarot specifically or its imagery.

The Divination Problem (1700s-1800s)

When tarot became associated with fortune-telling, Church opposition intensified.

Biblical Prohibition: Deuteronomy 18:10-12 forbids divination, sorcery, and consulting spirits. Fortune-telling with tarot violated this.

Usurping God's Authority: Claiming to know the future was seen as claiming God's knowledge, a form of pride and rebellion.

Demonic Deception: If tarot "worked," the Church argued it was through demonic powers, not divine revelation.

Exploitation of the Vulnerable: The Church (rightly) criticized fraudulent fortune-tellers exploiting desperate people.

The Occult Connection (1800s-1900s)

As tarot became linked to occultism, opposition grew more intense.

Occult Revival Fears: The Victorian occult revival alarmed religious authorities who saw spiritualism and magic as threats to Christian faith.

Satanic Panic Precursors: Tarot's Devil card, pentacles, and esoteric symbolism were seen as literally satanic.

Competing Spirituality: Tarot offered spiritual guidance outside Church authority, threatening institutional power.

Gender Dynamics: Women's involvement in tarot and spiritualism challenged male religious authority.

Legal Persecution

Religious opposition often became legal prohibition:

Fortune-Telling Laws: Many countries and cities banned fortune-telling for money, forcing tarot readers underground or into legal gray areas.

Vagrancy Charges: Tarot readers, especially women and Romani people, were arrested as "vagrants" or "confidence tricksters."

Obscenity Laws: Some jurisdictions tried to ban tarot imagery as "obscene" or "immoral."

Witch Hunt Echoes: In some places, tarot reading risked accusations of witchcraft, though actual witch trials had ended.

The Satanic Panic (1980s-1990s)

Modern evangelical Christianity launched intense anti-tarot campaigns:

"Doorway to the Occult": Tarot was portrayed as gateway to demon possession, satanism, and spiritual destruction.

Burning and Banning: Evangelical groups held book burnings including tarot decks. Schools banned tarot from campuses.

Chick Tracts: Jack Chick's anti-occult comics depicted tarot readers as demon-possessed and tarot as literally satanic.

Exorcism Claims: Some evangelicals claimed tarot users needed exorcism to remove demonic influence.

The Reality: No evidence supported claims of tarot causing harm. The panic was moral hysteria, not based on facts.

Catholic Church's Nuanced Position

The Catholic Church's stance has been more complex than simple condemnation:

Official Teaching: The Catechism warns against divination and consulting spirits, which would include tarot for fortune-telling.

Superstition Concern: The Church opposes treating tarot as having inherent power, seeing this as superstition.

Pastoral Approach: Many priests distinguish between tarot as psychological tool (acceptable) versus claiming supernatural knowledge (problematic).

Cultural Context: In Catholic countries like Italy and France, tarot has been more culturally accepted despite official Church teaching.

Why Tarot Survived

Despite centuries of opposition, tarot thrived:

Cultural Resilience: Tarot was too embedded in European culture to eliminate.

Underground Practice: Prohibition drove tarot underground where it continued secretly.

Secular Society: As societies secularized, religious authority over personal practices weakened.

Psychological Reframing: Jung and others reframed tarot as psychology, not religion, making it acceptable.

Spiritual Hunger: People sought meaning outside institutional religion; tarot filled that need.

Modern Acceptance

Today, tarot has largely won cultural legitimacy:

Mainstream Presence: Tarot in bookstores, museums, mainstream media without controversy.

Wellness Framework: Tarot as self-care, therapy, mindfulness - acceptable to secular culture.

Interfaith Dialogue: Some progressive Christians, Jews, and others integrate tarot with their faith.

Legal Protection: Fortune-telling laws mostly repealed or unenforced in Western countries.

Remaining Opposition: Fundamentalist Christians still oppose tarot, but they're cultural minority.

The Irony: Christian Tarot

Some Christians now use tarot:

Christian Tarot Decks: Decks with explicitly Christian imagery and interpretations.

Contemplative Practice: Using tarot for prayer, meditation, and spiritual reflection within Christian framework.

Archetypal Reading: Seeing tarot as universal archetypes compatible with Christian theology.

Controversy: This remains controversial among both Christians and tarot practitioners.

Lessons from Censorship History

Authority Fears Autonomy: Tarot threatened institutional control over spiritual knowledge.

Moral Panics Pass: The Satanic Panic seems absurd now; current fears may too.

Persecution Strengthens: Opposition made tarot more appealing, not less.

Truth Survives: If tarot had no value, censorship would have worked. Its survival proves its worth.

Bringing This History Into Your Practice

Honor the Persecuted: Remember those who risked arrest, condemnation, or worse to practice tarot.

Practice Openly: Where legal and safe, practice tarot openly. Visibility normalizes it.

Respect Boundaries: Don't force tarot on those whose faith forbids it. Respect their beliefs.

Sacred Space: Create space that honors tarot's resilience. Our Tarot Tapestries and Sacred Geometry Tapestries celebrate this tradition that survived persecution.

Educate: Share tarot's real history, not the myths and fears.

The Victory

Tarot won. Despite centuries of condemnation, burning, banning, and persecution, tarot is now mainstream. You can buy tarot at Target, study it at universities, display it in museums.

The Church's power to control spiritual practice has waned. Individual spiritual autonomy has won. And tarot, once condemned as demonic, is now recognized as a tool for self-knowledge, creativity, and personal growth.

From banned to beloved. From condemned to celebrated. The cards endure.