The Basque Witch Trials: Inquisition in Spain

Introduction: The Inquisition's Restraint

When we think of the Spanish Inquisition, we imagine torture chambers, auto-da-fés, and religious fanaticism. Yet in the witch hunts, the Spanish Inquisition was surprisingly more skeptical and restrained than Protestant courts in Germany, Scotland, or New England. Spain executed only about 300 people for witchcraft—a fraction of Germany's 25,000.

The exception was the Basque witch trials of 1609-1611, when mass hysteria swept the Basque region and thousands were accused. But even here, the Inquisition's response revealed a different approach: investigation, skepticism, and eventual rejection of witch hunt logic.

This is the seventh article in our Witch Hunts series. We now explore the Basque trials, the Inquisition's surprising role, and why Catholic Spain was less deadly than Protestant Europe in the witch hunts.

The Basque Region: Culture and Context

Geography and People

• Location: Northern Spain and southwestern France, Pyrenees mountains
• Language: Euskara (Basque), unrelated to any other European language
• Culture: Ancient, pre-Roman, fiercely independent
• Religion: Catholic, but with pre-Christian folk traditions

Folk Beliefs

• Mari: Pre-Christian goddess of the mountains
• Lamiak: Female spirits of rivers and caves
• Sorginak: Wise women, healers (later demonized as witches)
• Akelarre: Meadow of the he-goat (later associated with witches' sabbath)

Context: Basque folk religion blended with Catholicism, creating suspicion among Church authorities

The Logroño Trials (1609-1611): The Spark

The Beginning

1608: French witch hunter Pierre de Lancre conducted massive witch hunt in French Basque region (Labourd)

• 600+ accused
• 80+ burned
• Refugees fled to Spanish Basque country
• Brought stories of witches' sabbaths and Devil worship

1609: Panic spread to Spanish side

The Zugarramurdi Accusations

Location: Zugarramurdi, small Basque village near French border

November 1609: María de Ximildegui accused neighbors of witchcraft

Accusations:

• Attending sabbaths in caves
• Flying to sabbaths on broomsticks
• Worshipping the Devil (as a he-goat)
• Poisoning children and livestock
• Cannibalism and infanticide

The cave: Zugarramurdi cave (still exists) was identified as sabbath location

The Logroño Auto-da-Fé (November 7-8, 1610)

What happened: Public ceremony of penance and punishment

Numbers:

• 53 people tried
• 31 convicted
• 12 burned (6 alive, 6 in effigy—already dead)
• 18 reconciled (public penance, not executed)

Spectacle:

• Lasted two days
• 30,000 spectators (huge for the time)
• Procession through streets
• Public reading of sentences
• Burnings at the stake

Impact: Sparked mass panic across Basque region

The Panic Spreads (1610-1611)

The Numbers Explode

• 1610-1611: 7,000+ people accused in Basque region
• 5,000+ confessed (under pressure, not torture)
• Entire villages implicated
• Children as young as 7 accused

The Confessions

Typical confession:

• Attended sabbaths in caves or meadows
• Saw the Devil as a he-goat
• Kissed the Devil's anus (osculum infame)
• Danced naked, had orgies
• Ate babies and toads
• Made poisonous ointments
• Named other witches

Pattern: Confessions were remarkably similar, suggesting coaching or shared cultural script

Alonso de Salazar Frías: The Skeptical Inquisitor

The Investigation

Who: Alonso de Salazar Frías, junior inquisitor at Logroño tribunal

Task: Sent by Inquisition Supreme Council (La Suprema) to investigate the witch panic

Method:

• Traveled through Basque region (1611)
• Interviewed 1,802 alleged witches
• Examined evidence carefully
• Tested claims scientifically

The Findings

Salazar's conclusions:

• No physical evidence of sabbaths
• No poisoned ointments found
• No dead babies discovered
• Confessions contradicted each other
• Children's testimonies were coached
• Mass hysteria and suggestion, not real witchcraft

Famous quote:

"I have not found even indications from which to infer that a single act of witchcraft has really occurred."

The Report (1612)

Salazar's recommendations:

• Stop all witch trials
• Release all accused
• Ban discussion of witchcraft (to prevent panic)
• Require physical evidence, not just confessions
• Treat accusers with skepticism

Revolutionary argument: The real danger was not witches, but witch hunters

The Inquisition's Response: Restraint

La Suprema's Decision (1614)

The Inquisition Supreme Council accepted Salazar's findings:

• Issued new guidelines for witch trials
• Required physical evidence
• Banned torture for witchcraft accusations
• Prohibited trials based solely on confessions
• Effectively ended witch hunts in Spain

The 1614 Instructions

Key provisions:

• Inquisitors must be skeptical of witch accusations
• No trials without material evidence of harm
• Confessions under duress are invalid
• Children's testimony is unreliable
• Mass accusations indicate hysteria, not witchcraft

Result: Spain had virtually no witch executions after 1614

Why Was Spain Different?

Centralized Authority

• La Suprema: Central Inquisition council controlled all tribunals
• Appeals process: Local decisions could be overturned
• Trained inquisitors: Educated, followed procedures
• Bureaucracy: Slow, careful, evidence-based

Contrast: Germany's fragmented territories had no central control

Legal Tradition

• Roman law: Required material evidence
• Inquisitorial process: Judges investigated, not just accepted accusations
• Professional judiciary: Trained lawyers, not local amateurs

Theological Skepticism

• Focus on heresy: Inquisition cared about beliefs, not magic
• Doubt about Devil's power: God wouldn't allow Devil such freedom
• Concern about false accusations: Protecting innocent was priority

Practical Concerns

• Social stability: Mass trials destabilized communities
• Economic impact: Couldn't afford to lose population
• Reputation: Inquisition wanted to appear rational, not hysterical

Comparison: Spain vs. Protestant Europe

The Legacy: Zugarramurdi Today

The Cave

• Zugarramurdi cave is now a tourist site
• Museum of Witchcraft opened
• Annual witch festival (not celebrating persecution, but reclaiming history)

Cultural Memory

• Basque identity tied to resistance and independence
• Witch trials seen as Spanish oppression of Basque culture
• Folk traditions preserved and celebrated

Historical Recognition

• Salazar Frías recognized as early skeptic and rationalist
• His methods praised as proto-scientific
• Model for how institutions can resist hysteria

Conclusion: The Inquisition's Paradox

The Spanish Inquisition, infamous for religious persecution, was paradoxically more rational and restrained in witch trials than Protestant courts. The Basque trials began with hysteria but ended with skepticism, investigation, and institutional reform. Salazar Frías's work saved thousands of lives and showed that even in an age of superstition, reason could prevail.

In the next article, we will explore Scotland's Witch Hunts: The North Berwick Trials. We will examine why Scotland had one of Europe's highest per-capita execution rates, the role of King James VI, and the trials that inspired the king's obsession with witchcraft.

Spain burned 300. Germany burned 25,000. The difference was not theology, but institutions.

For the 12 burned at Logroño. For the thousands accused in the Basque panic. For Salazar Frías, who chose reason over fear. We remember.