The Way of Zen: Watts' Introduction to Eastern Thought

BY NICOLE LAU

The Way of Zen (1957) is Alan Watts' masterwork—the most comprehensive and accessible introduction to Zen Buddhism ever written for Western audiences. In this book, Watts traces Zen's development from Indian Buddhism through Chinese Taoism to Japanese Zen, explains its core principles with remarkable clarity, and shows how Zen practice can transform consciousness and life. By bridging Eastern wisdom and Western understanding, Watts made Zen comprehensible without diluting its depth, creating a classic that has introduced millions to this profound philosophy.

The Structure: Background and Principles

Watts organized the book into two complementary parts:

Part One: Background and History

The origins: Traces Zen's roots in Indian Buddhism, particularly the teachings of the Buddha on suffering, impermanence, and no-self. Shows how Buddhism evolved from the Buddha's original insights through various schools.

The Chinese transformation: Explains how Buddhism merged with Chinese Taoism to create Ch'an (Zen), absorbing Taoist emphasis on naturalness, spontaneity, and the Tao. This fusion created something new—neither purely Buddhist nor purely Taoist.

Japanese development: Describes how Ch'an became Zen in Japan, developing distinct schools (Rinzai and Soto) and integrating with Japanese culture, arts, and aesthetics.

The purpose: Understanding Zen's historical development helps Western readers grasp why it differs from other forms of Buddhism and how it relates to their own philosophical traditions.

Part Two: Principles and Practice

Core teachings: Explains fundamental Zen concepts—emptiness, no-mind, satori (awakening), the nature of reality, and the relationship between form and emptiness.

Practice methods: Describes zazen (sitting meditation), koan study, and the role of the Zen master. Shows how practice leads to direct realization.

Zen arts: Explores how Zen influenced Japanese arts—tea ceremony, calligraphy, archery, gardening—showing Zen as a way of life, not just meditation.

Key Concepts Explained

The Nature of Zen:

Beyond words: Zen emphasizes direct experience over conceptual understanding. As the saying goes, Zen is "a special transmission outside the scriptures, not founded upon words and letters." It points directly to the mind to see one's true nature.

Sudden awakening: Unlike gradual paths emphasizing step-by-step progress, Zen teaches sudden awakening (satori)—a direct, immediate realization of one's Buddha-nature. This can happen in an instant, though preparation may take years.

Ordinary mind is the Way: Enlightenment isn't something exotic or supernatural but recognizing the extraordinary in the ordinary. "Before enlightenment, chop wood, carry water. After enlightenment, chop wood, carry water."

Emptiness (Sunyata):

Not nothingness: Emptiness doesn't mean things don't exist but that they have no fixed, independent essence. Everything is interdependent, constantly changing, empty of separate self-nature.

Form is emptiness, emptiness is form: The famous Heart Sutra teaching that Watts explains brilliantly. Things appear solid and separate (form) but are actually fluid and interconnected (emptiness). These aren't opposites but two ways of seeing the same reality.

Practical meaning: Understanding emptiness frees us from attachment and fixed views. When you see that nothing has permanent essence, you can flow with change rather than resisting it.

No-Mind (Mushin):

Beyond thinking: No-mind doesn't mean unconsciousness but consciousness without the constant chatter of discursive thought. It's the state of pure awareness, responding spontaneously without mental interference.

The mirror mind: Zen uses the metaphor of a mirror—it reflects everything clearly without holding onto any image. No-mind is like this—fully present and responsive without clinging to thoughts.

In action: No-mind is the state of the master swordsman, the tea ceremony practitioner, the calligrapher—complete absorption in the present moment, action without the sense of a separate actor.

Spontaneity (Tzu-jan):

Natural action: Spontaneity in Zen means acting naturally, without forcing or artificiality. It's wu-wei (effortless action)—doing without the sense of a doer, like water flowing downhill.

Beyond control: The ego constantly tries to control and manipulate. Spontaneity means letting go of control and trusting the natural intelligence of life itself.

Cultivated naturalness: Paradoxically, spontaneity in Zen arts comes through rigorous training. The master calligrapher practices for years to achieve the spontaneous brushstroke. Discipline creates freedom.

Zen Practice: Zazen and Koans

Zazen (Sitting Meditation):

Just sitting: In Soto Zen, zazen is shikantaza—"just sitting." No goal, no technique, no trying to achieve anything. Simply sit with full awareness, letting thoughts come and go without attachment.

The posture: Watts describes the traditional posture—cross-legged, spine straight, hands in cosmic mudra, eyes half-open. The body's stillness supports the mind's stillness.

Not concentration: Zazen isn't concentrating on something but open awareness of everything. It's relaxed alertness, not forced focus.

The purpose: Zazen isn't a means to enlightenment but the expression of enlightenment. You don't sit to become Buddha; you sit as Buddha. The practice itself is realization.

Koans:

What they are: Koans are paradoxical questions or statements that can't be answered through logic. Famous examples: "What is the sound of one hand clapping?" "What was your original face before your parents were born?"

The purpose: Koans short-circuit the rational mind, forcing you beyond conceptual thinking to direct insight. They're not riddles to be solved intellectually but barriers to be broken through.

The practice: In Rinzai Zen, students meditate on koans, bringing them to the master for verification. The master can tell from the student's response whether genuine insight has occurred.

Watts' explanation: He shows how koans work by exhausting the mind's attempts to grasp reality conceptually, creating an opening for direct perception beyond thought.

Zen and the Arts

Watts dedicates significant space to how Zen influenced Japanese arts:

The Tea Ceremony (Chanoyu):

Meditation in action: The tea ceremony is Zen practice expressed through the simple act of preparing and serving tea. Every movement is deliberate, mindful, and aesthetic.

Wabi-sabi: The aesthetic of imperfection, impermanence, and incompleteness. The tea bowl with a crack, the asymmetrical flower arrangement—beauty in imperfection reflects Zen's acceptance of reality as it is.

Presence: The ceremony creates a space of complete presence—host and guests fully engaged in this moment, this tea, this encounter.

Calligraphy and Painting:

Spontaneous expression: Zen calligraphy and painting emphasize spontaneity and directness. The brushstroke can't be corrected or redone—it must be perfect in the moment.

Empty space: What's not painted is as important as what is. The empty space (ma) allows the painted elements to breathe and creates dynamic tension.

No-mind in art: The master artist paints from no-mind—the brush moves spontaneously without conscious planning. The art expresses the artist's Buddha-nature directly.

Archery and Martial Arts:

Zen in the Art of Archery: Watts references Eugen Herrigel's famous account of studying Zen archery. The archer doesn't aim and shoot; the shot happens by itself when the archer becomes one with bow, arrow, and target.

Martial arts: Aikido, kendo, and other martial arts incorporate Zen principles—no-mind, spontaneity, flowing with the opponent's energy rather than opposing it.

The Constant Unification Perspective

Watts demonstrates how Zen points to universal truths:

• Zen = Christian mysticism: Both emphasize direct experience of the divine, transcendence of ego, and union with ultimate reality—different languages, same realization
• No-mind = Flow state: What Zen calls no-mind, modern psychology calls flow—complete absorption in present activity
• Emptiness = Quantum physics: Zen's teaching that things are empty of fixed essence aligns with quantum physics showing reality as interconnected energy fields
• Satori = Mystical awakening: Zen's sudden awakening is the same experience described by mystics across all traditions

Watts' Unique Contribution

Making Zen Accessible:

Clear language: Watts explained Zen concepts in plain English without jargon or mystification. He showed that Zen isn't exotic or incomprehensible but addresses universal human concerns.

Western parallels: He constantly drew parallels with Western philosophy, psychology, and science, helping Western readers understand Zen in familiar terms.

Demystification: He removed the mystique and cultural trappings, showing Zen's essential insights applicable to modern Western life.

Preserving Depth:

Not oversimplified: Despite making Zen accessible, Watts didn't dumb it down. He preserved the paradoxes, the rigor, and the transformative challenge.

Scholarly foundation: The book demonstrates deep knowledge of Buddhist texts, Chinese and Japanese sources, and Zen history. It's accessible but not superficial.

Practical guidance: Watts provided enough detail about practice that readers could begin their own Zen exploration, not just understand it intellectually.

Practical Applications

Beginning Zazen:

Find a quiet space: Set up a simple meditation area with a cushion or chair. Simplicity is Zen.

Sit regularly: Start with 10-20 minutes daily. Consistency matters more than duration.

Just sit: Don't try to achieve anything. Simply sit with awareness, letting thoughts come and go like clouds.

Be patient: Zen practice is subtle. Don't expect dramatic experiences. The transformation happens gradually through regular practice.

Cultivating No-Mind:

Single-tasking: Do one thing at a time with full attention. When washing dishes, just wash dishes. This is no-mind in daily life.

Let go of commentary: Notice how the mind constantly comments on experience. Can you experience directly without the mental narration?

Trust spontaneity: Sometimes let yourself act spontaneously without overthinking. Notice how this feels different from calculated action.

Embracing Impermanence:

Notice change: Everything is constantly changing. Can you appreciate the beauty of impermanence rather than resisting it?

Wabi-sabi in life: Find beauty in imperfection, incompleteness, and transience. The cracked cup, the fading flower, the aging face—all beautiful in their impermanence.

Criticisms and Limitations

Not traditional Zen: Traditional Zen teachers sometimes criticized Watts for presenting Zen without the rigorous discipline and teacher-student relationship central to authentic practice.

Intellectual understanding: The book provides intellectual understanding of Zen, but Zen emphasizes direct experience beyond concepts. Reading about Zen isn't practicing Zen.

Cultural context: Some argue Watts stripped Zen of its cultural context, making it too Western and losing important elements.

Watts' response: He acknowledged the book was an introduction, not a substitute for practice. His goal was to make Zen accessible, not to replace traditional training.

Conclusion

The Way of Zen remains the best introduction to Zen Buddhism for Western readers. Alan Watts' ability to explain complex concepts clearly, his use of Western parallels and scientific language, and his preservation of Zen's depth while making it accessible created a classic that has introduced millions to this profound philosophy.

The book shows that Zen addresses universal human concerns—the nature of consciousness, the problem of suffering, the possibility of awakening. By presenting Zen as practical philosophy applicable to modern life rather than exotic Eastern mysticism, Watts made it relevant and accessible.

For modern seekers, The Way of Zen provides both understanding and inspiration. It explains what Zen is, how it developed, and how to practice it. More importantly, it points beyond itself to direct experience—the heart of Zen. As Watts would say, the book is a finger pointing at the moon; don't mistake the finger for the moon itself.

In our next article, we'll explore Watts' teaching on the illusion of the ego, examining how recognizing the separate self as a fiction can liberate us from suffering and open us to our true nature as the universe itself.

---

This article is part of our Western Esotericism Masters series, exploring the key figures who shaped modern mystical practice.