The Consciousness Philosophy of Mysticism: Awareness as Ground

BY NICOLE LAU

The Hard Problem

What is consciousness?

This is philosophy's "hard problem" (David Chalmers): How does subjective experience—the felt quality of redness, the taste of coffee, the sense of "I"—arise from objective matter?

Materialist neuroscience says: Consciousness is produced by the brain. Neurons fire, and somehow, mysteriously, experience emerges.

But this creates an unbridgeable explanatory gap: How do physical processes generate subjective experience?

Mysticism offers a radically different answer: Consciousness is not produced by matter—it's the ground in which matter arises.

This is not naive idealism ("only mind exists"). It's a sophisticated ontological claim: Consciousness is fundamental, not derivative.

Understanding this transforms everything—from how we see ourselves to how we engage with reality.

Three Philosophical Positions on Consciousness

Position 1: Materialism (Consciousness as Byproduct)

Claim: Matter is fundamental. Consciousness is an emergent property of complex material systems (brains).

Model: Matter → Brain → Consciousness

Strengths:

• Aligns with scientific materialism
• Explains correlation between brain states and conscious states
• Avoids "spooky" non-physical entities

Problems:

• The Hard Problem: Cannot explain how physical processes generate subjective experience
• The Combination Problem: How do unconscious particles combine to create consciousness?
• The Explanatory Gap: No amount of neuroscience explains why there's "something it's like" to be conscious
• Ignores phenomenology: Treats first-person experience as epiphenomenal (causally inert)

Mystical Critique: Materialism confuses correlation with causation. Brain activity correlates with consciousness, but that doesn't mean brain produces consciousness.

Position 2: Idealism (Matter as Manifestation of Consciousness)

Claim: Consciousness is fundamental. Matter is a manifestation or appearance within consciousness.

Model: Consciousness → Perception → Matter (as experienced)

Strengths:

• Solves the Hard Problem (consciousness is primary, not derivative)
• Aligns with direct experience (we only know reality through consciousness)
• Explains why observation affects quantum systems

Problems:

• Seems to deny the independent existence of the physical world
• Difficult to explain intersubjective agreement (why do we all see the same world?)
• Risks solipsism (only my consciousness exists)

Mystical Refinement: Not naive idealism ("matter doesn't exist"), but consciousness is the ground in which matter appears.

Position 3: Panpsychism / Dual-Aspect Monism (Consciousness and Matter as Two Aspects)

Claim: There is one fundamental reality with two aspects—objective (matter) and subjective (consciousness). Neither produces the other; they're complementary.

Model: Unified Reality ⇄ {Matter (objective aspect), Consciousness (subjective aspect)}

Strengths:

• Avoids both materialism's Hard Problem and idealism's solipsism
• Explains mind-matter correlation (they're two sides of the same coin)
• Aligns with quantum mechanics (wave-particle duality, observer effect)
• Allows for degrees of consciousness (panpsychism: all matter has some degree of interiority)

Mystical Position: This is closest to mysticism's view—consciousness and matter are not separate substances but dual aspects of a unified ontological ground.

Consciousness Is Not in the Brain—The Brain Is in Consciousness

The materialist assumption: Consciousness is localized in the brain.

The mystical insight: The brain is a localized pattern within a non-local field of consciousness.

The Analogy: Radio vs. Transmitter

Materialist view: The brain generates consciousness (like a radio generates music)

Mystical view: The brain receives/filters consciousness (like a radio receives broadcast signals)

Evidence for the filter model:

• Near-death experiences: Consciousness continues when brain activity ceases
• Psychedelics: Reducing brain activity (via serotonin agonists) expands consciousness, not reduces it
• Meditation: Quieting brain activity leads to heightened awareness
• Savant syndrome: Brain damage sometimes enhances certain abilities

These suggest: The brain constrains/focuses consciousness rather than producing it.

Consciousness as Field, Not Localized Entity

At Layer 4 (Consciousness), awareness is non-local—it's a field, not a thing.

Your individual consciousness is like a localized excitation of the universal consciousness field—similar to how a wave is a localized excitation of the ocean.

The wave is not separate from the ocean. Your consciousness is not separate from universal consciousness.

The Participatory Universe: Observer and Observed Co-Arise

Quantum mechanics revealed: The observer affects the observed.

Mysticism extends this: The observer and observed are not separate—they co-arise within a unified field of awareness.

The Participatory Principle

Physicist John Wheeler proposed the participatory anthropic principle: The universe requires observers to exist. Observation is not passive—it's participatory.

Mysticism agrees: Consciousness doesn't just observe reality—it participates in creating it.

This is not "you create your own reality" in a naive sense. It's: Reality and consciousness are co-creative.

The Möbius Strip of Knowing

In a Möbius strip, inside and outside are continuous—there's no boundary.

Similarly: The knower and the known are continuous.

When you observe a tree:

• The tree appears in your consciousness (tree → consciousness)
• Your consciousness shapes how the tree appears (consciousness → tree)
• Both arise within a unified field (consciousness ⇄ tree)

Subject and object are distinctions within consciousness, not separate entities.

Consciousness as Variable: Not Byproduct, But Causal Force

In materialist science, consciousness is treated as epiphenomenal—a byproduct with no causal power.

In mysticism, consciousness is a variable in the equations of reality—it has causal efficacy.

The Expanded Equation of Reality

Traditional physics: E = mc² (energy, mass, speed of light)

Mystical ontology: Reality = f(M, E, I, C)

Where:

• M = Matter (Layer 1)
• E = Energy (Layer 2)
• I = Information (Layer 3)
• C = Consciousness (Layer 4)

And C is not just a passive observer—it's an active variable that influences M, E, and I.

Evidence for Consciousness as Causal

1. Observer Effect (Quantum Mechanics)

Observation collapses the wave function. Consciousness determines which possibility becomes actual.

2. Placebo Effect

Belief (conscious state) causes measurable physiological changes. Consciousness → Matter.

3. Psychosomatic Phenomena

Mental states (stress, trauma, joy) directly affect physical health. Consciousness → Energy → Matter.

4. Intention Experiments

Studies (e.g., Dean Radin, Lynne McTaggart) show focused intention affects random number generators, plant growth, and water crystallization. Consciousness → Information → Matter.

5. Meditation and Neuroplasticity

Conscious practice (meditation) physically rewires the brain. Consciousness → Brain structure.

Levels of Consciousness: Individual, Collective, Universal

Consciousness is not monolithic—it has levels or scales.

Level 1: Individual Consciousness

What It Is: Your personal awareness—the "I" that experiences, thinks, feels.

Characteristics:

• Localized (associated with a specific body)
• Bounded (has a sense of "me" vs. "not-me")
• Temporal (experiences past, present, future)
• Egoic (identifies with thoughts, emotions, body)

Mystical Insight: This is the surface level of consciousness—real but not ultimate.

Level 2: Collective Consciousness

What It Is: Shared awareness—family consciousness, cultural consciousness, species consciousness.

Characteristics:

• Transpersonal (extends beyond individual)
• Shared fields (collective unconscious, morphic fields)
• Archetypal (contains universal patterns)
• Influences individuals (cultural conditioning, collective beliefs)

Examples:

• Jung's collective unconscious (shared archetypal patterns)
• Rupert Sheldrake's morphic fields (species memory)
• Collective emotions (mass panic, collective joy)
• Cultural consciousness (shared values, worldviews)

Mystical Insight: You're not just an isolated individual—you're a node in a collective consciousness network.

Level 3: Universal Consciousness

What It Is: Cosmic awareness—the ground of all being, pure consciousness itself.

Characteristics:

• Non-dual (no subject-object split)
• Infinite and eternal
• Self-aware (consciousness conscious of itself)
• The source and container of all other levels

Names Across Traditions:

• Brahman (Hinduism)
• Dharmakaya (Buddhism)
• The Tao (Taoism)
• The One (Neoplatonism)
• God/Godhead (Christian mysticism)
• The Absolute (philosophy)

Mystical Insight: Your deepest nature is this universal consciousness. Individual consciousness is a localized expression of it.

The Relationship: Nested, Not Separate

These levels are not separate—they're nested:

Universal Consciousness contains Collective Consciousness contains Individual Consciousness

Like Russian dolls—each level includes and transcends the previous.

And the boundaries are permeable:

• In meditation, individual consciousness expands into universal consciousness
• In group rituals, individual consciousness merges into collective consciousness
• In mystical experiences, all boundaries dissolve

The Witness: Pure Awareness Beyond Content

One of mysticism's deepest insights: You are not your thoughts, emotions, or experiences—you are the awareness that witnesses them.

The Distinction: Content vs. Awareness

Content: Thoughts, emotions, sensations, perceptions—everything that appears in consciousness

Awareness: The unchanging witness, the "I" that knows all content but is not identical to any content

Example:

• You have a thought: "I'm anxious."
• But who is aware of the anxiety?
• There's the anxiety (content) and the awareness of anxiety (witness).
• The witness is not anxious—it simply observes anxiety.

The Unchanging Witness

Content changes constantly:

• Thoughts come and go
• Emotions arise and pass
• Sensations fluctuate
• Perceptions shift

But awareness itself doesn't change. It's the constant background in which all change occurs.

This is why mystics say: "You are the sky, not the clouds."

Clouds (thoughts, emotions) come and go. The sky (awareness) remains.

Realizing the Witness: The Core Mystical Practice

Meditation is fundamentally about shifting identification from content to awareness:

• From "I am my thoughts" to "I am the awareness of thoughts"
• From "I am my emotions" to "I am the awareness of emotions"
• From "I am my body" to "I am the awareness of the body"

This shift is liberating—you're no longer trapped in the content. You're the spacious awareness in which content arises.

Non-Dual Awareness: The Ultimate Realization

The deepest mystical realization: Even the witness-content distinction dissolves.

From Dual to Non-Dual

Dual awareness: Subject (witness) observing object (content)

Non-dual awareness: No separation between subject and object—pure awareness aware of itself

In non-dual awareness:

• There's no "I" separate from experience
• There's just experiencing—no experiencer and experienced
• Awareness and its content are one

This is Advaita (non-duality) in Hinduism, Sunyata (emptiness) in Buddhism, Unio Mystica in Christian mysticism.

The Paradox of Non-Dual Awareness

Non-dual awareness cannot be fully described because description requires duality (describer and described).

It can only be realized directly.

But pointers:

• "I am That" (Tat Tvam Asi)
• "Form is emptiness, emptiness is form"
• "The kingdom of God is within you"
• "Consciousness is all there is"

Implications: Living from Consciousness

If consciousness is fundamental, several profound implications follow:

1. You Are Not Your Brain

Your identity is not limited to your body or brain. You are a localized expression of universal consciousness.

2. Death Is Not Annihilation

If consciousness is not produced by the brain, then brain death doesn't mean consciousness death. The localized expression dissolves, but consciousness itself continues.

3. You Are Connected to All

At the deepest level (universal consciousness), separation is illusory. You are intimately connected to all beings.

4. Your Consciousness Matters

Consciousness is causal. Your awareness, intention, and attention shape reality. You're not a passive observer—you're a participant.

5. Meditation Is Not Relaxation—It's Ontological Investigation

Meditation is exploring the nature of consciousness itself. It's not just stress relief—it's discovering what you fundamentally are.

Conclusion: Consciousness as Ground

Mystical consciousness philosophy offers a coherent alternative to materialism:

• Consciousness is fundamental, not derivative (solves the Hard Problem)
• The brain filters/localizes consciousness, doesn't produce it
• Observer and observed co-arise in a participatory universe
• Consciousness is a causal variable, not epiphenomenal
• Consciousness has levels: Individual, Collective, Universal
• You are the witness (pure awareness), not the content
• Ultimate realization: Non-dual awareness

This framework is:

• Philosophically coherent: Resolves problems in materialism and naive idealism
• Empirically grounded: Aligns with quantum mechanics, phenomenology, and contemplative science
• Experientially verifiable: Can be directly realized through meditation and contemplation

In the next article, we'll explore Mystical Mind Philosophy—the non-locality of mind, collective unconscious, and why telepathy and synchronicity are natural consequences of field-based consciousness.

---

This is Part V of the "Philosophy of Mysticism" series. Part I: The Ontology of Mysticism | Part II: The Epistemology of Mysticism | Part III: The Causality of Mysticism | Part IV: The Time Philosophy of Mysticism