Eclectic Wicca & Cultural Appropriation: Navigating Respectfully
Share
The Challenge of Eclecticism
Eclectic Wicca's greatest strength — its freedom to draw from multiple traditions and cultures — is also its greatest ethical challenge. When practitioners borrow practices, symbols, deities, and rituals from cultures other than their own, they enter complex territory that requires careful navigation.
Cultural appropriation — the adoption of elements from a marginalized culture by members of a dominant culture, often without understanding, respect, or permission — is a genuine concern in eclectic Wicca. It is also a topic that generates significant heat and sometimes more heat than light. This article aims to provide a thoughtful, nuanced framework for navigating these questions as an eclectic practitioner.
What Is Cultural Appropriation?
Cultural appropriation is not simply the act of learning about or being influenced by another culture. Human cultures have always influenced each other; the exchange of ideas, practices, and symbols across cultural boundaries is part of how cultures grow and develop.
Cultural appropriation becomes problematic when:
- Elements are taken from a marginalized or oppressed culture by members of a dominant culture
- The elements are used without understanding their original context and meaning
- The use causes harm to the source community — by misrepresenting their traditions, commodifying their sacred practices, or contributing to their erasure
- The source community has explicitly asked that their practices not be adopted by outsiders
The distinction between appropriation and appreciation — between harmful borrowing and respectful engagement — is not always clear-cut, but it is worth making the effort to understand it.
Why Eclectic Wicca Is Particularly Vulnerable
Eclectic Wicca's openness to drawing from multiple sources makes it particularly susceptible to appropriation. Common examples include:
- Using Native American smudging practices (particularly white sage and the term "smudging") without understanding their sacred context
- Adopting Hindu concepts (chakras, karma, namaste) as decorative spiritual accessories
- Using African diasporic religious symbols (veves, orishas) outside their proper context
- Claiming to practice "shamanism" without genuine training in any specific shamanic tradition
- Adopting closed religious practices — those that require initiation or community membership — as if they were freely available
Open vs. Closed Practices
One of the most useful frameworks for navigating these questions is the distinction between open and closed practices:
Open Practices
Open practices are those that the source community has made available to outsiders — either explicitly or through the nature of the tradition itself. Many ancient traditions — Greek, Roman, Egyptian, Norse — have no living community of practitioners who can claim ownership of the practices. These traditions are generally considered open to respectful engagement by anyone.
Some living traditions are also open — their practitioners actively share their practices with outsiders and welcome engagement. Buddhism, for example, has a strong tradition of missionary activity and welcomes practitioners from all backgrounds.
Closed Practices
Closed practices are those that the source community has explicitly restricted to members of that community — typically because they require initiation, lineage, or community membership to be practiced properly and safely. Examples include:
- Lakota sweat lodge ceremonies
- Vodou initiation and practice
- Certain Native American ceremonial practices
- Some aspects of Santeria and Candomblé
Closed practices should not be adopted by outsiders, regardless of how appealing they may seem. This is not about gatekeeping — it is about respecting the boundaries that communities have set around their own sacred traditions.
Practical Guidelines for Eclectic Practitioners
Research Before You Borrow
Before incorporating any practice, symbol, or deity from another culture into your practice, research it thoroughly. Understand its original context, its meaning within the source tradition, and the community's relationship to it. This research should include sources from within the source community, not just outsider accounts.
Ask Whether the Practice Is Open or Closed
Has the source community made this practice available to outsiders? Have they explicitly asked that it not be adopted? If you cannot find clear guidance, err on the side of caution.
Give Credit
When you incorporate elements from other traditions, acknowledge their origins. Do not present borrowed practices as your own invention or as part of "ancient Wiccan tradition."
Support the Source Community
If you benefit from another culture's spiritual practices, find ways to support that community — through purchasing from Indigenous artists and businesses, supporting organizations that advocate for their rights, and amplifying their voices.
Be Willing to Be Corrected
If a member of the source community tells you that your use of their practices is harmful or disrespectful, listen. Do not become defensive. Thank them for the correction and adjust your practice accordingly.
Work with Your Own Heritage
Many eclectic practitioners find that working with the spiritual traditions of their own cultural heritage — even if those traditions are not Wiccan — provides a rich and ethically uncomplicated source of material. If you have Celtic, Norse, Mediterranean, or other European ancestry, those traditions are particularly relevant to the Wiccan framework and are generally considered open to practitioners of that heritage.
Specific Situations
White Sage and Smudging
White sage is a plant sacred to many Native American traditions, and the practice of burning it for purification — often called "smudging" — has been widely adopted in the New Age and Pagan communities. Many Native American practitioners have asked that non-Natives stop using white sage and the term "smudging," particularly as the plant has become overharvested due to commercial demand.
Alternatives: Use other herbs for smoke purification — rosemary, lavender, mugwort, or cedar (which has a different cultural context). Use the term "smoke cleansing" rather than "smudging."
Chakras
The chakra system is a concept from Hindu and yogic traditions. It has been widely adopted in Western New Age and Pagan practice, often in forms that bear little resemblance to the original system. Using chakra concepts is generally considered acceptable if done with genuine understanding and respect for their origins.
Deities from Living Traditions
Working with deities from living religious traditions — particularly those of marginalized communities — requires particular care. Deities from ancient traditions with no living community of practitioners (Greek, Roman, Egyptian, Norse) are generally considered more accessible. Deities from living African diasporic traditions (Vodou, Santeria, Candomblé) are typically closed and should not be adopted without proper initiation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it appropriation to use runes if I'm not Norse?
The Norse/Germanic runic tradition is generally considered open to practitioners of European heritage and, by many practitioners, to anyone who approaches it with genuine respect and study. There is no living community of practitioners who claim exclusive ownership of the runes.
Can I work with deities from cultures I'm not part of?
This depends on the tradition. Ancient traditions with no living community are generally more accessible. Living traditions, particularly those of marginalized communities, require more caution. Research the specific tradition and listen to voices from within it.
What if a deity calls to me from a culture I'm not part of?
Many practitioners report genuine experiences of being called by deities from cultures other than their own. If this happens, approach the deity with respect, research their tradition thoroughly, and be open to the possibility that the call may be to learn about the tradition rather than to adopt its practices wholesale.
As you walk your path with intention and respect, let your practice be guided by thoughtful alignment with the energies you wish to cultivate, perhaps beginning with 40 manifestation rituals intention to reality to anchor your intentions, or exploring 13 new moon rituals lunar beginnings for fresh starts steeped in awareness; deepen your self-reflection through tarot journaling prompts 100 questions for self discovery, and honor your sacred space with a sacred space cleanse printable energy clearing ritual kit to clear away any unintentional echoes, all while wrapping yourself in the protective presence of the archangel michael tapestry as a reminder that reverence, not appropriation, is the true foundation of a mystical life.
