Pagan vs Heathen: Umbrella vs Specific
Share
BY NICOLE LAU
The Path Label Battle
Both pagan and heathen describe non-Abrahamic spiritual paths, but they have different scopes and meanings. Understanding their differences helps you identify your path accurately and use the right terminology respectfully.
Pagan: The Umbrella Term
Energy: Broad, inclusive, diverse traditions
Best For:
- Describing non-Abrahamic earth-based spirituality
- Inclusive term for many different paths
- General identification with nature-based religion
- Covering Wicca, Druidry, Hellenism, and more
- Broad spiritual community
How It Works: Pagan is an umbrella term covering many different earth-based, polytheistic, or nature-honoring spiritual paths. It includes Wicca, Druidry, Hellenism, Kemeticism, eclectic paganism, and many other traditions. If you practice any non-Abrahamic, nature-based spirituality, you can identify as pagan.
Feel: Inclusive, broad, diverse. Like being part of a large, varied spiritual family.
Heathen: The Specific Path
Energy: Specific, Norse/Germanic, reconstructionist
Best For:
- Following Norse/Germanic pre-Christian traditions
- Honoring Norse gods (Odin, Thor, Freyja, etc.)
- Reconstructing historical Northern European practices
- Specific cultural and ancestral focus
- Asatru, Forn Sidr, or Norse paganism
How It Works: Heathen specifically refers to those who follow Norse, Germanic, or Anglo-Saxon pre-Christian traditions. Heathens honor the Norse gods, celebrate Norse holidays, and often focus on reconstructing historical practices. It's a specific subset within the broader pagan umbrella.
Feel: Specific, ancestral, culturally focused. Like connecting to particular Northern European roots.
Key Differences
Scope: Pagan is broad umbrella; heathen is specific tradition.
Cultural Focus: Pagan includes many cultures; heathen is Norse/Germanic specific.
Deities: Pagans honor various pantheons; heathens honor Norse/Germanic gods.
Relationship: All heathens are pagan, but not all pagans are heathen.
The Venn Diagram
Heathenry is a subset of paganism. If you're heathen, you're also pagan (though some heathens prefer not to use the pagan label). But if you're pagan, you're not necessarily heathen—you might be Wiccan, Druid, Hellenic, eclectic, or any other pagan path.
Which Are You?
You're Pagan if:
- You practice any earth-based, polytheistic, or nature-honoring spirituality
- You follow any non-Abrahamic spiritual path
- You want a broad, inclusive term for your practice
You're Heathen if:
- You specifically follow Norse/Germanic traditions
- You honor the Norse gods and celebrate Norse holidays
- You're reconstructing Northern European pre-Christian practices
- You identify with Asatru, Forn Sidr, or Norse paganism
Terminology Note
Historically, both "pagan" and "heathen" were derogatory terms used by Christians for non-Christians. Both communities have reclaimed these terms as positive self-identifiers. Use them respectfully and only for those who self-identify with them.
The Bottom Line
Pagan is your umbrella term—broad, inclusive, covering many earth-based spiritual paths. Heathen is your specific path—Norse/Germanic focused, reconstructionist, particular cultural tradition. All heathens are pagan, but not all pagans are heathen. Pagan is the big tent; heathen is one specific tradition within it. Use the term that accurately describes your specific practice.
As you explore these ancient paths, remember that both traditions honor the deep rhythms of the earth and sky, and the tools you choose can help anchor your practice in meaningful ways — consider grounding your rituals with the sacred presence of the archangel michael tapestry, aligning your intentions with the cosmic alignment ritual kit for syncing with the celestial flow, or reflecting on your journey through the the 52 week tarot journey a year of weekly spreads daily pulls deep reflection.
